Posts
Review: Coronavirus and Christ
Coronavirus and Christ by John Piper
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
View all my reviews
Tuesday, July 7, 2020
Monday, June 29, 2020
Friday, June 26, 2020
Thursday, May 28, 2020
Review: Shaping a Digital World: Faith, Culture and Computer Technology
Shaping a Digital World: Faith, Culture and Computer Technology by Derek C. Schuurman
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Ðe following review I wrote while annoyed by unruly fellow airplane passengers leaviŋ þeir small children uſe noiſy electronic toys, so I may have lacked long-sufferiŋ.
It is quite grave that Schuurman speaks as looſely as he does, never riſiŋ above the common ſenſe, on a falſely so called teχnology — properly defined it is the ſtudy of teχnique, and that he does not do, doing little more than enumeratiŋ politically correct talking points in a neoevangelical varnish. His inſufficiency in dealiŋ with the ſubſtance of what he mentions lead to diſinformation, for example when he writes about free ſoftware licenſiŋ — as the name implies, it is licenſed, not given away, unleß it is releaſed to the public domain, which is actually quite rare — or, even worſe, when he uses the propaganda term ‘intellectual property’ for the four diſparate inſtitutes of time limited, artificial, government-created & granted private monopolies of copy rights, letters patents, trade marks & trade ſecrets.
Ellul refused ðe word technology, sticking to more modest & precise technic, & for good reason: use of such high sounding, academic-like lingo, as incidentally foreign words for concepts already present in the vernacular, obscures how prosaic is ðe world around us — & its temptations.
Moreover, it has been a long time since I read such a badly thrown together book. When I wrote just above that he enumerates politically correct talking points, I was quite literal — the text (one can barely call it a book) lacks a flow of articulate ideas, so the reader feels thrown away hiþer & tiþer, wiþout knowing whence ðe auþor (one is tempted to call him a compiler instead, but even so there are more readable compilations) comes from or where he goes.
I would like to note it even lower, if not for his at least mentioning free ſoftware. Even ſo, I was let down for I came to this book becauſe ſomeone ſaid it contained a defenſe of free ſoftware baſed on Dooyeweerd‘s categories; it does mention a very superficial justification of free ſoftware, and it does liſt Dooyeweerd‘s categories, but it never tries to articulate free ſoftware — nor oðer stuff he mentions — to Doyeeweerd’s categories. Even worſe, ðe type of diſinformed Christian who sees no ißues wiþ usiŋ private, proprietary ſoftware will not probably ſtomach enough of Schuurman’s political correctneß to even read enough to reach his ſhort, unarticulated mention on ðe rationale for free ſoftware.
Anoðer letdown was ðat ðe blurb promised Schuurman drew on Ellul, but he has noþiŋ of ðe Reformed trenchant demolition of idols Ellul had, even if Ellul ſurpriſingly was an Univerſalist.
A friend aſked quite appropriately why ðen four ſtars. I feel ðis title could provoke a better converſation deſpite its flaws.
View all my reviews
Review: Shaping a Digital World: Faith, Culture and Computer Technology
Shaping a Digital World: Faith, Culture and Computer Technology by Derek C. Schuurman
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Ðe following review I wrote while annoyed by unruly fellow airplan passengers leavin þeir small children use noisy electronic toys, so I may have lacked long-suffering.
It is quite grave that Schuurman speaks as loosely as he does, never rising above the common sense, on a falsely so called technology — properly defined it is the study of technique, and that he does not do, doing little more than enumerating politically correct talking points in a neoevangelical varnish. His insufficiency in dealing with the substance of what he mentions lead to disinformation, for example when he writes about free software licensing — as the name implies, it is licensed, not given away, unless it is released to the public domain, which is actually quite rare — or, even worse, when he uses the propaganda term ‘intellectual property’ for the four disparate institutes of time limited, artificial, government-created & granted private monopolies of copy rights, letters patents, trade marks & trade secrets.
Ellul refused ðe word technology, sticking to more modest & precise technic, & for good reason: use of such high sounding, academic-like lingo, as incidentally foreign words for concepts already present in the vernacular, obscures how prosaic is ðe world around us — & its temptations.
Moreover, it has been a long time since I read such a badly thrown together book. When I wrote just above that he enumerates politically correct talking points, I was quite literal — the text (one can barely call it a book) lacks a flow of articulate ideas, so the reader feels thrown away hiþer & tiþer, wiþout knowing whence ðe auþor (one is tempted to call him a compiler instead, but even so there are more readable compilations) comes from or where he goes.
I would like to note it even lower, if not for his at least mentioning free software. Even so, I was let down for I came to this book because someone said it contained a defense of free software based on Dooyeweerd‘s categories; it does mention a very superficial justification of free software, and it does list Dooyeweerd‘s categories, but it never tries to articulate free software — nor oðer stuff he mentions — to Doyeeweerd’s categories. Even worse, ðe type of disinformed Christian who sees no issues wiþ using private, proprietary software will not probably stomach enough of Schuurman’s political correctness to even read enough to reach his short, unarticulated mention on ðe rationale for free software.
Anoðer letdown was ðat ðe blurb promised Schuurman drew on Ellul, but he has noþing of ðe Reformed trenchant demolition of idols Ellul has, even if Ellul is surprisingly an Universalist.
View all my reviews
Tuesday, May 19, 2020
Saturday, March 28, 2020
Tuesday, March 24, 2020
Review: Stargazing Dog
Stargazing Dog by Takashi Murakami
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
View all my reviews
Wednesday, March 11, 2020
Wednesday, March 4, 2020
Saturday, February 15, 2020
Review: The Kingdom of God: A Baptist Expression of Covenant Theology
The Kingdom of God: A Baptist Expression of Covenant Theology by Jeffrey D. Johnson
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
The book is actually three works in one. The first is a very good exposition of Baptist fœderalism, focusing on the dichotomous nature of the Abrahamic covenant, a feature missed by Presbyterian & Congregationalists that is the Achiles’ heel of their systems, with the application of it to issues of law & grace.
The second is a retelling of the Biblical storyline. I guess it might be deemed quite good, but I guess I am not wired to its format & style. It was a chore, to be blunt.
The third is a few pages of application of Baptist fœderalism to the New perspective on Paul. It was quite refreshing how it solves not only the perplexities of baby sprinkling, but also of new approaches to Paul.
View all my reviews
Monday, December 30, 2019
Review: Never Try to Arouse Erotic Love Until . . .: The Song of Songs, in Critique of Solomon: A Study Companion
Never Try to Arouse Erotic Love Until . . .: The Song of Songs, in Critique of Solomon: A Study Companion by Calvin G Seerveld
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
A very surpriſiŋ — at leaſt to me — take on Ðe Soŋ of ſoŋs as a dramatic poem between a decadent, polygamous Salomon, ðe Shulamite he preſumably had kidnapped, ðe Shulamite’s country lover & a chorus of harem women. Starts very well, ðen wanders off a bit tryiŋ to find applications on friendſhip & ðe like, but ðen finiſhes well wiþ ðe Soŋ itſelf ſet dramatically.
View all my reviews
Friday, December 20, 2019
Review: Percevejos, ideólogos — e alguns escritores
Percevejos, ideólogos — e alguns escritores by Rodrigo Gurgel
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Eßencial. Entre recuperações de eſcritores injuſtamente olvidados, amiúde por motivos inconfeßáveis, e demolições de autores idolatrados, Gurgel expõe em crítica o que já expuſera como jurado do Jabuti — que Machado de Aßis continua certo em sua Teoria do medalhão.
View all my reviews
Saturday, November 30, 2019
Review: The Wandering Earth: Classic Science Fiction Collection
The Wandering Earth: Classic Science Fiction Collection by Liu Cixin
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Very imaginative. But the author, being a man of his time, fails to transcend the already obsolete worries of global anthropogenic warming & deforestation; worse, he cavalierly dismisses transcendence as being an evolutionary result of our ‘surface’ civilisation.
View all my reviews
Monday, November 11, 2019
Review: The Remnant of Israel: The Theology, History, and Philosophy of the Messianic Jewish Community
The Remnant of Israel: The Theology, History, and Philosophy of the Messianic Jewish Community by Arnold G. Fruchtenbaum
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
An interesting book, but deeply flawed. Some flaws are more relevant than others. My guts & personal theological preferences would have me give only three stars, but for the questions it raised it gets four, even when I disagree with the answers.
The major flaw is that it pressuposes dispensationalism. It would be a oh-so-much better book if it dealt with different escathologies and covenantalisms. Specially fruitful would be explorations of new covenantalism, progressist covenantalism and Baptist 1689 federalism.
A minor irk is its use of Jewish forms of New testament names, such as Messiah instead of Christ. But that is understandable given both the Hebrew origins of the Greek names, and the propensity of Jews to use Hebrew names for religious concepts.
Another irk is the amount of text about legalism, which is relevant perhaps to US fundamentalism but feels like a surpassed issue already.
Perhaps it would need a third edition.
View all my reviews
Tuesday, November 5, 2019
Review: The Man in the High Castle
The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Very interesting alternate history, with a few oddities:
First, the victory of the Axis seems to hinge upon Roosevelt having died before the New Deal could recover the United States — but it seems today that the New deal delayed recovery instead of aiding it. Also, upon the whole Pacific fleet being destroyed in Pearl harbour, which is a near impossibility. Russia seems to have collapsed in 1941, which seems more credible. But all these are trifles.
Second, all religion seems to be centered on the I Ching. Even with Jews and reputedly Protestants. This seems a major flaw, specially as there is so much superstition and even extase around.
Third, in 1962 Nazis are both carrying out an African genocide and colonizing Mars. Both too soon after the war. And the Japanese crimes of war are altogether ignored, to the point of idealizing the Pacific coprosperity sphere.
Fourth, the language is very strange, sounds to me ungrammatical. For example, articles and pronouns are often absent. Not sure if it is supposed to reflect an evolution of language under Japanese influence or whatever, but again it would have been too soon.
Fifth, the ending is altogether obscure. It never becomes clear why after all the German and Japanese would have lost the war in winning it. Perhaps because they will destroy each other, but a bit of clarity would have been welcome, even if under the guise of a sequel.
View all my reviews
Tuesday, October 29, 2019
Review: The Fatal Flaw of the Theology Behind Infant Baptism
The Fatal Flaw of the Theology Behind Infant Baptism by Jeffrey D. Johnson
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
A very clear take on a complicated subject. Forceful, yet irenic. I may be biased: I do not see how one cannot see the force of the evidence & arguments presented, even if I may disagree on his take on New covenant theology.
View all my reviews
Saturday, September 28, 2019
Review: アンゴルモア 元寇合戦記 5
アンゴルモア 元寇合戦記 5 by Nanahiko Takagi
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Good art, interesting historical setting. Could be less explicit.
View all my reviews
Friday, September 27, 2019
Review: From Jerusalem to Irian Jaya: A Biographical History of Christian Missions
From Jerusalem to Irian Jaya: A Biographical History of Christian Missions by Ruth A. Tucker
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Quite engrossing. I almost gave it four stars for its theological latitudinarianism, but it really brings the History of Christian (in quite a wide sense of ‘Christian’) missions alive.
View all my reviews
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
